Gamers still joke about Geralt's crossbow in The Witcher 3, which is useless on land and deadly underwater
Video game logic bends physics more freely than any sorcerer. But when the same weapon barely scratches a nekker on land and sends a drowner to the bottom with a single shot underwater, that's a whole other level of selective natural law.
This is about the hand crossbow in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. A fresh Reddit meme reminded players that bolts deal far more damage underwater, and the aim locks onto the nearest enemy on its own. Plenty of people only find this out dozens of hours in. One player admitted to spending almost a hundred hours just running from drowners and sirens, while another never once tried shooting underwater but drowned countless times.
The logic behind the decision is easy to guess. Underwater, Geralt loses his sword and Signs, which leaves the crossbow as his only argument. One-shot kills with auto-aim look like a patch that makes underwater combat technically possible without driving players up the wall. On Death March, though, the contrast gets comical: a drowner shrugs off a dozen silver sword hits but drops from a single bolt.
On land, the crossbow fills a narrow niche. Back in the White Orchard tutorial, the game shows that it's meant for knocking flying creatures like the griffin out of the sky, after which the sword takes over. Still, Aard, which the bestiary recommends against many winged monsters, and Axii do the same job. One player summed up the contradiction like this:
Yeah crossbow that has enough stopping power to drop Basilisk or Archgriffin from sky while also being barely strong enough to make scratch on nekker skin
Around this odd mechanic, players have built up a whole collection of tricks and quirks. Bleed bolts work well against sirens attacking the boat, since a single tick of damage is usually enough to drop the creature dead. Yrden with the glyphword that creates a trap, if cast from a boat, leaves flat circles hanging in the water – useless, but pretty. In the Last Wish quest, the corpses of slain drowners sometimes float up in a pile and block the boat or even flip it over. The dream of proper underwater Signs hasn't gone anywhere: Aard underwater would turn Geralt into a true mantis shrimp, and those hopes are now shifting to the announced The Witcher 4.
Geralt has hunted monsters for decades, and in the end drowners fear anything but his sword.
- Console gamers got mods for The Witcher 3 and a ton of bugs: one player was left with only Geralt's head and two swords
- The Witcher 3 fans are upset that the remaster literally destroyed the cozy charm of golden Toussaint
- The Witcher 3 fans split into two camps: some complain about overly drastic combat changes, while others don't notice them at all