Fallout 4 veteran discovers that playing as the Railroad makes more sense if you join it at the very beginning

The order in which you play a big RPG can shape how you see its story more than any dialogue choice. The same faction can look like a bunch of weirdos in a basement, or like the only force that has spent years fighting the Wasteland's biggest threat alone. It all comes down to when the hero knocks on the door.

In Fallout 4, released in 2015, the effect is especially obvious with the Railroad. The usual route runs through Concord, the Cambridge police station, Diamond City, the hunt for Kellogg, the Prydwen, and the Glowing Sea. By the time the player meets the underground network, the hero is typically tied to the Minutemen, the Brotherhood of Steel, or the Institute, and the Railroad is reduced to a chip decryption and some ballistic weave for armor.

One player decided to start a new survival run differently and went to the Railroad as soon as he heard about it in Diamond City. According to him, that approach makes the whole story more coherent. The logic is solid: with no other allies in sight, the Sole Survivor looks for anyone fighting the people who took Shaun.

Players can tell Desdemona straight out that they are joining for purely selfish reasons, and she couldn't care less. Before the teleport to the Institute, the character can even repeat that their son matters more than any synths. A marriage of convenience turns into a real alliance once it becomes clear what Shaun has grown into. The cherry on top comes after the return from the mission, when the hero finds their own name crossed out on the agents board – they have already been buried.

The password to the hideout in the Old North Church has long been a running joke. After finishing the Freedom Trail, the player enters the word RAILROAD on a rotating dial, which is simply the name of the organization. The setup does have an in-game justification, though. The Trail works as a test: Deacon watches the candidate the whole way, and Desdemona wants cameras installed along the route. The door only lets the visitor into a place where they will either be talked to or ambushed. Isaac Marion, author of Warm Bodies, who also writes for games, offered a much more down-to-earth explanation:

I can guarantee you the writer did not know how easy the password was going to be when they wrote that line. Maybe it used to be something hard and player tests showed nobody could figure it out so they dumbed it down.

Marion added that voice acting is recorded early and can't be redone afterward, while game design keeps changing until the last minute. When teams aren't tightly synced, dialogue starts to look like nonsense.

The saddest part is that the Railroad had the potential for much more. Its conflict with the Institute was already hinted at in Fallout 3, where agent Victoria Watts said the organization helped not only synths but ordinary slaves too, working with other abolitionists. By the events of Fallout 4, only wreckage remains after the fall of the Switchboard headquarters, as the terminals describe in detail. Still, for a battered cell that the Institute keeps cutting down again and again, sticking to a single goal makes sense.

The Railroad has nothing to offer except a basement and a password taken from its own name, and for a hero who has nothing left either, that is plenty.

Tags: