YouTuber played Exodus and The Expanse: Osiris Reborn and named the main differences
YouTuber MrHulthen has published a comparison of two sci-fi RPGs set to launch in 2027. He spent roughly eight to nine hours with Exodus and another four to five in The Expanse: Osiris Reborn.
The two games are often pitted against each other, but the blogger urges fans not to hunt for a winner. Both could appeal to Mass Effect fans, even though they offer quite different experiences.
Setting
In his view, the biggest difference lies in the setting and tone of the storytelling. The Expanse: Osiris Reborn from Owlcat Games sticks to the principles of hard sci-fi.
The action unfolds in the Solar System, the technology has not strayed far from what exists today, and the world rests on realistic physics and political conflicts between humans. Alien elements are present, but the game is nowhere near the scale of Mass Effect, with its galactic community of diverse races.
Exodus, by contrast, leans toward space opera with fantasy elements. The story takes place 40,000 years in the future, in a distant cluster above the Milky Way.
Over that time, humanity has evolved into Celestials – nearly godlike beings with incredible powers. They, in turn, created new species, including changelings. The game also features enormous intelligent animals and unusual technology, down to weapons that can talk to their owner.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere differs just as much. The beta of The Expanse: Osiris Reborn left MrHulthen with the impression of a lighter, more laid-back game. Even amid firefights, the dialogue and the starting area feel slightly quirky, and the banter between characters is not short on humor.
Exodus makes a completely different impression. A crushing atmosphere hangs over it, carried by the music, the world design, and the anticipation of heavy decisions. Protagonist June spends most of his time somber and lost in thought.
Controls set the games apart as well. June movement feels heavy and substantial, with the weight of the character coming through in jumps, rolls, and cover transitions.
In The Expanse: Osiris Reborn, the hero moves faster and responds more sharply, but the motion sometimes feels too light, almost weightless. The blogger prefers the Exodus approach and would like Owlcat Games to give the controls a bit more physical heft.
Combat
Even so, he rated the combat systems of both RPGs highly. Among his favorite abilities in The Expanse: Osiris Reborn, MrHulthen singled out the Harbinger nanobot swarm, and he named the zero-G fight as the best part of the beta.
Exodus has a similar section, but the sound design stood out most to the blogger. Synth effects accompany nearly every action, from shooting to rolling and taking cover. He also praised the exploding spear that June launches with his gauntlet.
Dialogue
The Expanse: Osiris Reborn has the edge here for now. The beta gives players far more dialogue options and ways to investigate what is going on. MrHulthen liked being able to question characters, dig for details, and choose exactly how to steer a conversation.
In Exodus, decisions more often boil down to two options, though some conversations branch out more.
Presentation
Archetype Entertainment game wins that round on presentation. Exodus scenes resemble a Hollywood space opera, with more expressive character animations and conversations that look more cinematic.
The blogger links this partly to the difference in budgets and would like to see more scenes like that in The Expanse: Osiris Reborn, especially during chats with squadmates.
"Killer features"
In The Expanse: Osiris Reborn, squadmates on the ship help out in situations like blowing apart a space station or fighting enemies. Accepting or declining their help affects relationships with them for better or worse.
Exodus is expected to feature a time dilation mechanic. It is still unclear whether it will become a full gameplay system or remain a story device.
According to the YouTuber, Exodus bets on large-scale decisions whose consequences will reach future generations. In The Expanse: Osiris Reborn, the results of actions show up right away.
Companions
Owlcat Games has a knack for creating attractive characters. He jokingly called Regina "Miranda 2.0," a nod to Mass Effect. MrHulthen expects more from Archetype Entertainment on that front, though he noted that Suleiman already has the potential to become one of those characters.
Verdict
In the end, the blogger declined to pick between the two RPGs. He called both spiritual successors to Mass Effect and admitted that these are exactly the kind of sci-fi games he wants right now.
They are exactly what I want from this industry right now. These are sci-fi RPGs. They're different and they have different feelings, they have different tones, and they approach things differently. We're going to be eating good next year. You don't have to choose.
Exodus is set to release on April 7, 2027, on PC, PS5, and Xbox Series. The Expanse: Osiris Reborn has no release date yet.