Gamers compiled a list of games in which the hero has to fight on the losing side
Most war games put the hero on the winning side – one soldier turns the tide of battle while enemies drop in droves. Some developers take a different route, showing the conflict through the eyes of those already losing, where every victory only postpones the inevitable.
One gamer recently asked for recommendations for exactly that kind of game. Genre and era didn't matter, and within a few days the thread had collected hundreds of replies, from cult shooters to grim strategies and survival sims. The clear winner was a game whose ending players knew long before it came out.
Halo: Reach
The most popular answer was a predictable one. From the first mission, players know how the story of the planet Reach ends – its fall has been canon since the original Halo. By the fourth mission, it's clear that Noble Team is just watching an entire world die.
Many still can't shake a line from Kat that was quoted dozens of times in the thread:
I know we're losing. I want to know if we've lost already.
Players also recalled the "Exodus" level in burning New Alexandria, the sacrifice of George, who died believing he had saved the planet, and the endlessly repeating message about a slipspace rupture being detected. Commenters added that the hopelessness runs through almost the entire series, from Halo: Combat Evolved, where the captain hands Master Chief a pistol with no ammo, to Halo 3: ODST.
World in Conflict
The 2007 strategy game from Massive Entertainment tells the story of a sudden Soviet invasion of the US, and things start out very badly for the Americans. Players spoke most warmly of the last-stand mission at Cascade Falls, with many calling it the best defense in gaming history.
One user suggested playing the eighth mission to a track by Godspeed You! Black Emperor and warned that tears are possible. Others recalled that the collector's edition came with a piece of the Berlin Wall, and that the Soviet Assault expansion lets players see the conflict from the other side.
Resistance
The Insomniac Games trilogy for PS3 is set in an alternate history where alien Chimera, rather than World War II, descended on Earth. Every skirmish comes at a steep cost, with victories that feel Pyrrhic and defeats that feel crushing.
According to players, level design creates the atmosphere. Empty towns whose residents died only recently, radio broadcasts from burning cities, and crowds of allied soldiers dying to push the front line forward make you feel like part of a huge, doomed army.
This War of Mine
The 11 bit studios game shows war through the eyes of those who lose in every war – civilians. Users shared stories that, in their words, still turn their stomachs.
User aferretwithahugecock:
One of my characters went to a bombed-out grocery store looking for food and left his daughter with the newest member of the group. He saw a soldier about to rape a woman and shot him, but the bullets didn't get through the body armor, and the soldier killed him on the spot. The newcomer went to the market and got shot by a sniper. She survived, but her injuries kept her from finding food, and the little girl starved to death.
One commenter joked that the launch party must have looked like a group of people silently staring into space around a cake. Another noted that "hard mode" in this game is surviving a long winter as a single parent with a child.
Mass Effect
The BioWare trilogy got a mention for its constant feeling that the odds are stacked against the hero. It shows most clearly in the third game, where the Reapers invade and bankers in one background conversation discuss how the galaxy has about a year to win before the war economy collapses.
The Arrival DLC for the second game, which leads directly into the events of Mass Effect 3, got its own shout-out. Some sad comments about the fate of BioWare itself followed.
Gears of War: E-Day
The latest prequel in the series covers the start of a war that will last about 17 years and wipe out most of the planet. Players pointed out that you pass through the same locations several times, and they look worse each time.
The game just goes from "oh, we're screwed" to "oh, we're REALLY screwed" to "HOW DID IT GET THIS BAD?!"
Total War: Attila
The Western Roman Empire campaign is arguably the clearest example among strategy games. Players described it as a feast on Rome's corpse – everyone attacks the empire even before the Huns arrive, so simply surviving counts as a win.
Veterans shared tips. Many recommend tearing down expensive churches, abandoning most provinces, and digging in across Spain and North Africa, where the front line is minimal, then gradually reclaiming Italy and Gaul.
Myth: The Fallen Lords
The 1997 strategy game was remembered for its rare honesty. Users pointed out that most games about a lost war suffer from a gap between story and gameplay – the story says everything is dire, while in combat the player stays unbeatable.
Story: the enemy is an endless horde of ancient horrors. We're barely surviving. We're doomed. Gameplay: the enemy is an endless horde of ancient horrors. We're barely surviving. We're doomed.
HighFleet
Players called the airship battleship strategy game a perfect example of feeling like the odds are against you. Many admitted they never finished it, and that when a certain piece of battle music kicks in, they know the outcome is already decided against them.
XCOM
Both modern XCOM games from Firaxis came up for the constant sense of being behind, especially before plasma weapons arrive. Players joked that the series teaches one key lesson – even a 95% chance is far from a guarantee.
Metro
The games based on Dmitry Glukhovsky books were recalled for their bleak vision of Moscow, where survivors hide in the metro from mutants while warring stations try to wipe each other out. Commenters especially liked the original versions, whose atmosphere, by general agreement, was partly lost in the remasters.
Last Train Home
The strategy game follows the Czechoslovak Legion, which fights its way across Siberia to Vladivostok after World War I in order to get home. The detachment faces Reds, Whites, warlords, and bandits, while the player has to keep an eye on the wounded, hunger, and morale.
Arma 3
Users noted that the first chapters of the campaign revolve around simple survival, and the feeling of victory only arrives in the third. The Antistasi mod got a separate mention, where a squad of eight insurgents with a crate of World War II-era weapons gradually grows into an army, then runs into a far more brutal invading force.
Helldivers 2
The Galactic War in the Arrowhead Game Studios shooter sparked a debate. Some players think the current state of affairs creates just the right sense of hopelessness. Others are convinced they're fighting less against enemies than against a game designer who hands out deliberately impossible missions.
Other recommendations included The Banner Saga, WARSAW, The Forever Winter, Black Mesa with its desperate radio chatter from surrounded soldiers, the "Last Tiger" mission from Battlefield V, and Space Marine 2. Jokes came too – many admitted that any real-time strategy game, any Hearts of Iron IV campaign, and any match of the shooter Wardogs on the blue team gives them the feeling of a lost war.