Players are unhappy that Crimson Desert was named PC game of the year at the Golden Joystick Awards
Crimson Desert won PC Game of the Year at the Golden Joystick Awards, but the argument is less about the win itself and more about who the game was up against. Many people called the nominee list strange, and some players flat-out wrote that there was barely any competition.
The nominees were:
Big Walk
Escape from Tarkov
Esoteric Ebb
Meccha Chameleon
Mewgenics
Order of the Sinking Star
Star Wars Zero Company
The Blood of Dawnwalker
Valheim
Only The Blood of Dawnwalker and Star Wars Zero Company are generally named as real rivals for Crimson Desert in terms of scale and quality. Tarkov and Valheim draw their own complaints, since both spent years in early access.
One commenter argued that a game shouldn't be eligible years after launch just because it hit version 1.0.
The thin list is partly down to how the ceremony is set up. Console games get their own category, so Resident Evil Requiem competed for the top award of the year and wasn't in the PC category. The ceremony also takes place in early November, which means winter releases don't count.
Commenters explained that otherwise reviewers would have to rate December releases within a matter of days, so the cutoff is shifted.
Another storyline revolves around the votes themselves. The Golden Joystick winners are picked by players, and one participant in the discussion couldn't resist some irony:
Unhappy people show up to complain that their anime game or indie didn't win, even though at any other time they considered user votes the only ones that matter.
Fans of Crimson Desert don't argue that the game is for everyone, either. Critics have been repeating for years that the world feels empty and the story is weak, and IGN gave the game a 6 out of 10.
Supporters point to the scale of the open world, the freedom of action, and the hundreds of hours they have sunk into it. Someone even recalled that Pearl Abyss released an entire patch to rework the story, which means the developer did hear the complaints after all.
The calmest reactions came from those who simply reminded everyone of what game awards are worth. Winning a vote doesn't prove a game is good or bad, and toxic arguments around winners come back after every ceremony.
Pearl Abyss got the trophy, and everyone else got questions about the nominee list.
- Pearl Abyss significantly improved Crimson Desert's combat system but didn't tell anyone
- Cat in a diving helmet becomes the main star of the Crimson Desert expansion
- Crimson Desert patches will be released less frequently because the studio has redirected all its efforts to creating expansions