Many gamers consider Dwemer, silver and glass swords the most beautiful in Skyrim, while contemptuously calling Daedric weapons "fantasy junk from a ninja store"

In RPGs, damage numbers rule everything, right up until taste gets involved. Plenty of heroes have carried a clearly weaker blade for a hundred hours simply because it looks like a family heirloom rather than a prop from a teenage fantasy.

On November 11, The Elder Scrolls 5: Skyrim turns 15, and players are still arguing about its arsenal. On Reddit, one gamer asked which vanilla sword looks the best, then answered with the Dwarven one himself. In his words, the blade is simple and straightforward, and the only thing keeping it from perfection is a leather wrap on the grip.

Commenters brought up the Nordic sword from the Dragonborn add-on, the glass blades with their greenish sheen, and the dragonbone greatsword. The last one gets praise for a symmetry that is rare in that weapon line.

Then there is the question of who got left out. Almost nobody mentioned the Daedric sword, the smithing peak and endgame weapon. One commenter said it looks like a "mall ninja sword," and another compared it to the jagged blades kids draw. One gamer laid out the complaints like this:

It feels like the kind of fantasy sword an overenthusiastic apprentice charcoal-sketches late at night and then sneaks into the forge to make when the master blacksmith's back is turned.

The problem is baked into Skyrim progression. The higher the material tier, the more spikes, curves, and extra flourishes appear, while iron and steel, which look like real medieval weapons, stay in beginner hands. Players point to The Lord of the Rings trilogy, where the weapons work because they look believable, and they don't hide their irritation that realistic design in the game automatically means weak. Hence the popularity of mods that redraw gear in a historical style. Ebony armor, for example, turns into Renaissance plate.

Even the favorites come with a catch, though. The Silver Sword, one of the most loved for its looks, can't be improved at the grindstone, and the Nightingale Blade is bugged and can't be tempered either. The cherry on top is that the Ebony Smithing perk bonus doesn't apply to that blade, so the Nightingale weapon often ends up on a display plaque. Dragonbone, on the other hand, wins on literalness: the blades resemble bone shards, the mace is made of teeth, and the warhammer is essentially a femur with a handle.

The Daedric sword hits hardest, but the one hanging on the wall in Whiterun is the silver one.

More news
Tags: