GOG has long been trying to re-release the 1992 strategy game Dune 2, which is stuck in licensing hell involving five rights holders
Westwood Studios 1992 release Dune 2: The Building of a Dynasty, known in some versions as Battle for Arrakis, laid the foundation for the entire real-time strategy genre. Its influence is plain to see in Blizzard's Warcraft and in Command & Conquer, which Westwood made itself. Still, the game has never gotten a modern re-release.
The reason is a tangled chain of licenses. The game is based on a movie, the movie is based on a novel, and the novel now has a new adaptation with its own tie-in game. Marcin Paczynski, senior business development and partnerships manager at GOG, has been trying to untangle this mess for a long time.
This is one of the holy grails. It's on the top of my list, my personal one, because this is a game that I have a lot of nostalgia for. The situation is a good example of how bad it can get with the licensing situation of a game.
Westwood Studios was eventually acquired by EA, which now holds the game code, assets, and all related materials. The IP itself is another story. As Paczynski explained, the Herbert Foundation doesn't own it directly either, since the games were based on the 1984 movie rather than the books.
That film was made by Universal Pictures, with Dino De Laurentiis as the main producer, and he kept part of the movie license. He died 15 years ago. According to Paczynski, whoever succeeded De Laurentiis "has a portion of them" – meaning those rights.
You have Universal Pictures, Electronic Arts, and the successor for the original rightsholder of the movie IP. On top of that, you have the Herbert Foundation that holds the rights to the IP as a whole, and on top of that, you have Legendary Pictures that owns the IP to the new movies.
Legendary adds a problem of its own. It gave Funcom the license to make games within the IP for Dune: Awakening, and Paczynski noted that "there is an exclusivity there." It's "currently not clear" how that would affect a re-release of the older Westwood Dune games, which also include Dune 2000 and Emperor: Battle for Dune.
"You have all of those multi-billion-dollar companies playing a role for a game that, if we released it, might sell, I don't know, like 50,000 units – maybe 100,000 – for $5.99 or $9.99," Paczynski concluded. "It's a good example of how complicated things can get."