Total War: Warhammer 3 fans are tired of playing Tom and Jerry with AI armies that constantly run away and avoid battles

The Total War series has sold players on massive battles with thousands of warriors clashing for years. In practice, a big chunk of any campaign turns into a game of tag on the world map, and the side running away is the one that's supposed to be attacking. When a bloodthirsty Khorne daemon like Skarbrand flees an enemy army for several turns in a row, things have reached a whole other level of madness.

The latest round of complaints started with a Reddit post whose author said they were tired of an endless game of "Tom&Jerry" in Total War: Warhammer 3. The player feels like half of a campaign goes to chasing enemy armies. Dwarfs, Skaven, and Greenskins are the worst, diving into underway tunnels and resurfacing somewhere that can't be reached in a single turn. It got to the point where the player installed the cheat tool Plitch and simply extended the movement range of their armies.

The root of the problem lies in how the AI judges strength. Before attacking, it compares army power much like auto-resolve does, and if the odds look bad, it simply turns around. Retreat distance is calculated in a straight line, ignoring terrain, so an army can "retreat" half a move and end up behind a river or mountain that costs the pursuer a full turn to get around. The AI also has strong resistance to attrition, without which its armies would just die off on the march. One player put it bluntly:

I can take the economy hit and I'm marching on it's capital. What the AI is doing is killing itself in the most unsatisfying way possible.

Skaven are a headache of their own. The rat-men churn out heroes that expose ambushes, and some of their lords can cut the movement range of every army in a region. One commenter even said their friends banned them from playing Skaven in a multiplayer campaign. Against the AI, though, there is a sneaky bait trick:

  • a lord on a fast mount with one or two cheap units stands at the edge of the enemy army range in a normal stance, with no ambush

  • the main army waits a little farther back, outside the bait reinforcement range and outside the enemy reach

  • the AI sees a lone, weak target and attacks, since it almost always thinks only one turn ahead

  • on the next turn, the enemy army ends up right next to the main force and can't escape

Many veterans with thousands of hours in the game had never thought of this approach. The complaint about the AI also runs deeper than it looks. Lords have traits like reliability and aggressiveness, but those barely affect army behavior, and the dream of factions that act true to the lore remains just a dream.

Khorne armies would throw themselves into suicidal attacks, Dwarfs would sit on defense, and Skaven cowardice would be cranked up to the maximum. Commenters also brought up Warhammer 2, where the AI was hyper-aggressive and hunted player armies rather than undefended minor settlements. Longtime players added that Karl Franz chasing Surtha Ek in the first game was even worse.

Archaon shows up with armies capable of ending the world, then turns around and leaves at the sight of Karl Franz with a single army.

Tags: