Claude started refusing the creator of a Pokemon fan game who spends up to $2,000 a month on AI
Anthropic changed the rules for its Claude language model to "prevent IP infringement." The AI is no longer supposed to help recreate existing games, and the first developer to feel it is the creator of the fan game Pokemon Arena 2D, which is built almost entirely with AI.
The developer, who goes by Big Kid Nation, described the problem on X. Claude models are increasingly refusing to work on his code.
Anthropic has cracked down and Claude models are starting to refuse work on Pokemon fan projects. All that money spent, never took a cent (unlike many others with itch io, patreon etc).
The costs are hefty. A month ago, Big Kid Nation tweeted that he spends "up to $2,000 expenses a month" on development and has put in "10-14 hour days both learning and bulding for most of this year." Accused of making plain "AI slop" with Pokemon Arena 2D, he answered:
My life went down hill. I lost everything. I'm here to achieve something. Pokemon is my entire childhood and this is everything to me now. I'll live in my car and set my computer up at the library every day if I have to keep going with 'AI slop.' Never gonna stop.
The game is made through vibe coding – the developer describes the features he wants in plain language, and the model writes and edits the code. The human mostly tests the results and comes up with new prompts instead of programming by hand.
Claude's updated rules include the line "don't build a recreation of a specific existing game." Strictly speaking, Pokemon Arena 2D doesn't copy any game in the series. It's an arena battler where players pick their creatures' moves in real time.
The visuals use sprites from a library put together by the Pokemon fan community. Without the familiar creatures and move names, the game could pass as a fresh take on the creature-battling genre. The brand, characters, and move names still belong to Nintendo, The Pokemon Company, and Game Freak.
A few weeks ago, Anthropic developer Addy Osmani tweeted that "using Claude to infringe IP is against our usage policy." Fan games, however original their mechanics, still infringe on someone else's rights. Without Claude, the future of Pokemon Arena 2D looks murky.
On the game's Discord server, Big Kid Nation admitted that development now leans almost entirely on AI:
It's almost exclusively vibe coded now. We are very pro AI for creative game development. Not because of 'Laziness' but because that's what's getting the best results. In quality and time. We want the best Pokemon project. We've got a growing human team though.
Anthropic's restrictions haven't pushed the developer to delay. Pokemon Arena 2D is still set for December 2026, and fans "shouldn't worry," he says. How the team plans to keep working without Claude, Big Kid Nation hasn't said.
- Claude solves problems better than candidates, and an Anthropic manager gave up coding interviews
- Claude stopped helping with reverse engineering and game cloning
- Japanese 3D artist used two AI models to create a room in Unreal Engine 5 without ever opening Blender