Skyrim designer admits he thought constellation skill trees were a silly idea by Todd Howard until the game's release
Making a game on the scale of Skyrim takes tight collaboration, and disagreements come with the territory. A longtime Bethesda developer recently recalled how he rejected Todd Howard's vision for character progression until players proved the director right.
Bruce Nesmith worked as a designer on Morrowind, Oblivion, and Skyrim. He told the story on The Examined Game podcast.
Todd had this vision for how the constellations would reflect your skills.
According to Nesmith, Howard was looking at the art and wanted it to drive how the skills related to one another.
I was like, "No, you're going up you're looking at these, why can't we just put a list out, it's far more functional. People are going to get confused by these constellations, it's not going to work, I'm not seeing it."
In Skyrim, the skill trees are literally made of stars in the night sky. That marked a striking visual departure from the number sets and lists of Oblivion, released in 2006. Each constellation represents a separate skill, and perks unlock as points on the star map.
Nesmith admitted he stuck to his position through the end of development.
I held that all the way through production, and the game gets out there, and people loved the constellations. They thought they were fantastic. I was clearly wrong.
The designer gave Howard credit for having both the better idea and enough authority to take the risk. Good collaboration needs someone at the helm who can sense the right direction when opinions split, no matter who came up with it. With the constellations, Howard was both the author of the idea and the one making the call.
Skyrim launched in November 2011. The next game in the series, The Elder Scrolls 6, is in development.
- After the announcement of The Elder Scrolls 6: Sentinel, gamers recalled Todd Howard's words about why Skyrim had no class selection
- 15 years later, Skyrim fans noticed that Todd Howard was playing a fully leveled mage during the demo
- Skyrim fan only learned after 200 hours in the game that he was supposed to sleep in a bed