Bethesda fans came to the defense of Creation Engine and pointed out where the studio's engine outperforms its competitors
Few pieces of tech in the industry get mocked as consistently as the Bethesda engine. Jokes about an "engine from the Morrowind days" have become a ritual that repeats after every trailer from the studio. The funny part is that most of the people making them probably couldn't explain what the engine actually does.
The engine in question is Creation Engine, which debuted in Skyrim in 2011 and grew out of Gamebryo, the tech behind Oblivion. The second version, Creation Engine 2, arrived with Starfield in 2023, and Todd Howard has already confirmed that The Elder Scrolls 6 will run on Creation Engine 3. The age argument falls apart at the first comparison, though: Unreal Engine dates back to 1998, and Rockstar RAGE, which powers GTA 6, appeared in 2006, which also predates Creation.
Another round of engine debate played out on Reddit after the Sentinel announcement, and in the comments, players laid out plenty of arguments for why it's actually very good. The engine's biggest strength is hard to spot in screenshots. Nearly every item in the world is a full physical object with a saved state, and NPCs follow schedules driven by the Radiant AI system, which first appeared in Oblivion.
In Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2, a game often cited as a counterexample, shelves are stuffed with prop books and half of Kuttenberg's houses have no interiors. One player described exactly how immersion breaks in that situation:
I'm suddenly hit with an awareness that 'objects i can see' and 'objects that are interactable' are now distinct classes.
That level of detail comes at a price, and anyone who complains about loading screens knows it well. The world is split into cells, which is the only way the engine keeps performance in check when rooms are packed with thousands of cheese wheels, and it also lets designers play tricks with scale. Breezehome in Whiterun looks noticeably smaller from the outside than its interior. In Starfield the trade-off is plainly visible: in New Atlantis, where there are fewer loads, the Jemison Mercantile store has almost no items you can pick up, while the closed-off shops of Akila City are full of them.
Starfield itself weakened the strengths of the engine more than it showed them off. Radiant AI there is cut down to minor NPCs and crew members, outposts and the clutter system fall short of Fallout 4, and a good chunk of resources went into simulating orbits, which is almost invisible in regular play. Interstellar travel turned into a chain of menus, unskippable takeoff and landing cutscenes, and loading screens, even though Starfield looked more stable at launch than many recent Unreal Engine 5 releases.
Bethesda seems to understand that swapping the engine wholesale makes little sense: in Oblivion Remastered, Unreal Engine 5 handles only the visuals, while all the game logic still runs on the old Gamebryo.
Loading screens could be dropped, but a table where every last spoon can be swiped is something Bethesda is unlikely to give up.