Scotland players in Crusader Kings 3 are unhappy that the country is forcibly subordinated to the Archbishop of York
The medieval church carved up the world as ruthlessly as any king, only with bulls and diocesan borders instead of swords. Those borders can outlast any crown. A player can crush enemies, found a personal rite, and seat a relative on the papal throne, yet still can't pull a country out from under someone else's archbishop.
That is the wall Scotland players hit in Crusader Kings 3 after the church overhaul that introduced rites, their heads, and clerical regions. Scottish counties default to the Archdiocese of York, and the split rules require a new region to be smaller than the one it breaks away from. Scotland is simply bigger than northern England, so even an independent kingdom can't leave York.
One player complained that all they wanted was "their own little region" where a foreign rite doesn't keep repainting their lands, and instead they got an endless tug of war over counties between Edinburgh and York.
The irony is that history went the other way. The archbishops of York did claim authority over Scottish dioceses, but local bishops and kings stubbornly refused to recognize it. In 1192, the papal bull Cum universi made the Scottish church a "special daughter of Rome," answerable directly to the pope. Scotland got its own archbishop only in 1472, at St Andrews, so the in-game situation more or less replays the 12th-century dispute, minus the outcome the Scots eventually won.
There is a workaround. Ask the pope to merge York with the Archdiocese of Canterbury first, then split Scotland off the enlarged region, since its territory will now be smaller than the English one. That takes a cardinal of your own near Rome, and sponsored cardinals have a habit of ending up outside diplomatic range. For those who tire of the scheming, manual save editing is another option: the clerical region manager section lets players assign each county directly.
Scotland isn't alone. Denmark can't break away from Hamburg either, even though Lund historically got its own archbishop around 1103–1104, and after a split the islands somehow stay with the Germans, a patchwork that even cheats can't fix. Sicily players have similar trouble, as the Roman archdiocese keeps converting Naples the moment they create their own rite. The comments answered with little mercy:
You've just asked the same question as all the Hauteville kings of Sicily and Frederick II von Hohenstaufen.
The Sicilian kings argued with popes for centuries, while a player needs only one campaign.