IGN China called Western AAA games industrial waste in its Phantom Blade Zero review – a very strange wording from the homeland of gacha

The IGN China review of Phantom Blade Zero goes beyond parries, combos, and the story of Soul, an assassin with 66 days left to live. The outlet also took a swipe at the entire Western industry, holding up the game from Beijing studio S-Game as proof of Chinese developers' superiority and calling major Western releases "industrial waste".

The core argument fits in a single sentence:

Western game creators are trapped in the dilemma of creative bottlenecks, kidnapped by politically correct elements...

The key to that line is the term itself. In Chinese gaming circles, "political correctness" (zhengzhi zhengque) refers to a fairly specific set of complaints: LGBT themes, "forced diversity," and characters that local audiences find unattractive.

The backlash peaked a few years ago, and the reviewer apparently aimed at that exact target rather than at Western culture as a whole.

In the West, the same debate has long boiled down to good writing versus bad. Baldur's Gate 3 has just as much diversity and still won near-universal love.

The catch is that the political correctness charge comes from a country where every game goes through state licensing. The Chinese version of World of Warcraft hid skeletons for years, Ubisoft nearly removed skulls from Rainbow Six Siege in 2018 for the Chinese market, and Wuchang: Fallen Feathers was rewritten after its July 2025 release over outrage from local players about the fate of historical figures.

As a result, bosses now literally come back to life after a fight, and reports of the team disbanding surfaced later. One Reddit commenter summed up the contrast in a single line:

Political correctness in the US is optional, in China it's mandatory.

That said, the IGN China argument is not entirely off base. While American studios cut staff and chased live-service games, Larian, FromSoftware, CD Projekt RED, Remedy, Housemarque, Capcom, and Game Science shipped new hits, most of them European and Japanese rather than Chinese.

China's own list of big wins is short so far. Wukong, Wuchang, and Phantom Blade Zero all share an ancient China action setting, while the industry still makes most of its money from mobile gacha games, which the majority of gamers in China play.

IGN China can lecture the West on creative freedom all it wants, but Chinese studios still have to answer to the leadership of the Communist Party.

More news
Tags: