The mechanic Blizzard cut from Diablo 3 has found the perfect home in World of Warcraft
A good idea doesn't always fit the game it was made for. Blizzard has an edge smaller studios lack: a solid mechanic that doesn't belong in one series can move to another. That's how a concept from an early version of Diablo 3 ended up at the heart of a raid encounter in World of Warcraft.
Wyatt Cheng, a former Blizzard game director, told the story on his Instagram. In 2004, he was on the team working on Diablo 3, which was experimenting with "set" monsters that followed the logic of equipment sets – the more pieces collected, the bigger the bonus.
Maybe a set monster pack is four enemies with one ability each, and each monster would grant its ability to the other three upon death. We prototyped it internally. It was not fun.
According to Cheng, the problem came down to the nature of Diablo itself. Action RPG players rarely study the enemies on screen, since they want the fastest kill and the best loot. The transfer of abilities between monsters mostly went unnoticed.
Work on that version of Diablo 3 was soon put on ice, and Cheng moved from Blizzard North to the World of Warcraft team, which was growing rapidly at the time. He was assigned boss encounters, and one of the fights involved four beefy enemies: the Anubisath Sentinels in the Temple of Ahn'Qiraj.
Every single reason set monsters failed in Diablo was solved right here.
In a raid, the mechanic worked differently. MMORPG players move as a coordinated group, scout enemies in advance, and keep an eye on every foe instead of rushing past in search of loot. The buffs the remaining sentinels received when one fell were impossible to miss and demanded careful tactics.
To add some RNG, Cheng made each Anubisath randomly pick an ability from a pool of eight. Every encounter differed from the last, and raids had to reassess the lineup each time, deciding which order to take the sentinels down.