Josh Sawyer explained why making city-based RPGs costs much more than "standard" ones

Obsidian design director Josh Sawyer answered a question about why there are so few RPGs set in contemporary urban environments. He did so in a new Q&A episode on his YouTube channel. According to Sawyer, such games are harder and more expensive to make than RPGs with the genre's usual locations.

He drew on his own experience at Obsidian and Black Isle.

One of the issues as an RPG developer that we've found–at least at Obsidian and Black Isle–is that, compared to a dungeon, generally speaking, a town is four times the expense per square foot, basically. Not really "square foot" but, if you have a map of a given size. If you have a dungeon that's this big, it costs X. If you have a town that's populated with people that feels realistic, that's four times as expensive.

Sawyer cautioned that this is a generalization, but one backed up by the studios' past games.

Obviously, that's a generalization, but that's something that is reflected in our [past] work. As we work on areas over time, when we get towards the end, we realize: 'Holy crap, we spent forever trying to do these maps.'

His example was Pillars of Eternity, where the team had to build the city of Twin Elms at the very end of development.

For example, at the end of [Pillars of Eternity], we had to do Twin Elms. And that was, one: A big pacing landmine that a lot of people did not appreciate–so, sorry about that. But also, we're back to doing very expensive content. You might ask: 'Well, what's the expense?'

There's a high density of NPCs, a lot of characters have dialogue. They have their own–maybe not super-unique appearances–but there's just a lot more custom stuff that goes into setting up towns, usually. They're more expensive. Obviously you can do it, though.

Elsewhere in the episode, Sawyer named RPGs that managed to create believable, dense urban spaces. They include Athkatla from Baldur's Gate 2, Disco Elysium, and the recent Zero Parades. He noted that the latter two have an advantage: they don't need to fit nearly as many combat encounters into their cities as other RPGs do.

Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines, Cyberpunk 2077, and the city from Baldur's Gate 3 could be added to that list. These games illustrate Sawyer's point about cost and difficulty well. Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines and Cyberpunk 2077 are known for troubled development cycles at their respective studios. Act 3 of Baldur's Gate 3, which takes place in the city, shows the most noticeable seams between the game's elements.

Still, urban adventures remain in demand, whether as part of a game or its entire setting. Novigrad and Oxenfurt in The Witcher 3 are often named among the most memorable places in the game.

Tags: